Log in

No account? Create an account
11 February 2010 @ 10:37 am
Making of Modern Britain; Sahara with Michael Palin  
We decided we'd start the evening with Andrew Marr's Making of Modern Britain, coz it was likely to be depressing viewing. This episode covered just 4 years - the First World War. And it was every bit as grim as we'd thought it would be. The sheer scale of the death & destruction, so much of it unnecessary even if you thought the war was necessary in the first place. Like the story of the Captain who'd worked out that if they went over the top when their orders said & headed in the direction they were supposed to, then they'd die. So he talked to his superiors, showed them his scale model & explained his reasoning ... and they got sent anyway, orders are orders. And they all died. Without doing anything useful, just died. And the level of incompetence from the leadership was staggering too - I mean, I know it was a new type of war & obviously they prepared based on lessons from their last conflict, but once it wasn't working it seemed like they just carried on. And screwed things up more directly too, like the Gallipolli campaign which sounded like it had been a clusterfuck from conception onward. And of course in retrospect the whole thing is even more of a senseless waste, coz it only took 30-odd years before it all went to hell again.

Then we had a break for xmas cake (we had a mini one in the hamper from my brother that we hadn't eaten yet) and a bit of a cheer up. And onto programme two - the much more light-hearted Sahara with Michael Palin. Unfortunately we'd not noticed it was on until episode 2, so we had to start there. In this one he was travelling from Senegal to Timbuktu (well, nearly), so covering a lot of the same ground in reverse that the last episode of the Lost Kingdoms of Africa had. Although filmed several years earlier & with a very different style to it ;) I wasn't convinced at first that it wasn't going to be on the wrong side of the line between entertaining & cringe-worthy and a few bits (the nightclub in Dakar for instance) definitely were. But overall it was a fun & entertaining watch. With some more serious subjects touched on enough to know they were there, like female circumcision and the fact that Dakar is the place that a lot of African slaves were transported from. Not quite sure how come Michael Palin gets to travel around asking people personal questions & have it received with such humour, tho ;) It was weird watching this so soon after the other programme though, coz we got to see the Dogon people again, with some similar footage (of the funeral dances) just a different slant on it.
Current Mood: contentcontent
Current Music: 80s stream
(Deleted comment)
Margaretpling on February 11th, 2010 02:04 pm (UTC)
Re: Hang on... what?

I can see why that might provide some cognitive dissonance ;)
(Anonymous) on February 11th, 2010 05:52 pm (UTC)
First World War
I think that there were more casualties due to the spainsh flu epidemic in 1918 than there were from all the battles during WW1 - It is estimated that anywhere from 50 to 100 million people were killed worldwide which is from three to seven times the casualties of the First World War (15 million)

Never trust a microbe !
Margaretpling on February 11th, 2010 05:57 pm (UTC)
Re: First World War
There's still something somewhat less brutally senseless about people dying of flu (or other misadventure) than dying coz somebody somewhere decided they should march into machine gun fire despite its uselessness!

(microbes only shoot you by accident! ;) )
cal_boudicca on February 11th, 2010 07:11 pm (UTC)
Hi! This is Tad Williams. Please excuse the interruption to your regularly scheduled bloggery. People here love fantasy and science fiction, so I just wanted to pop in and say that anyone interested in reading a chapter from my new book, SHADOWRISE, should drop an email to:


and we'll send one to you. We won't do anything rotten with your email address, either, we promise.

Thanks – Tad